Model the long-term profitability of SEO as a compounding asset against the linear returns of Google Ads to make a strategic investment decision.
SEO Total Profit
$459,869
Google Ads Total Profit
$87,000
Profit Crossover Point
Month 12
Comparing SEO and Google Ads is like the classic fable. Google Ads is the hare: it's incredibly fast, delivering traffic and leads from day one. However, it's a linear relationship—the moment you stop paying, the traffic stops. SEO is the tortoise. It starts slow, often with an initial period of negative returns. But as it builds momentum, its returns begin to compound, eventually overtaking the linear returns of PPC to build a sustainable, long-term asset.
The "J-curve" effect shown in the chart happens because SEO creates a flywheel:
The most successful brands don't choose one or the other. They use both in synergy:
PPC allows for precise control. You can direct traffic to a dedicated, highly optimized landing page designed for a single conversion action. Organic traffic, conversely, might land on various pages (blog posts, homepage, etc.) where the user's intent is more informational. However, with good on-page SEO and CRO, this gap can be narrowed significantly.
This is the strategy of appearing in both the paid and organic sections of the search results for your most important keywords. Studies have shown that brands with a presence in both sections see a higher overall click-through rate than the sum of their individual parts, as it creates a powerful signal of authority and trust to the user.
If you need leads immediately (e.g., for a new business or a time-sensitive promotion), PPC is the clear choice. If you are building a long-term brand with a focus on sustainable, profitable growth and have a time horizon of at least 6-12 months, SEO is a superior investment. For most established businesses, a combination of both is optimal.
PPC provides a linear return: you put $1 in, you get $X back. The moment you stop paying, the returns stop. SEO is a compounding asset. The work you do in month 1 (e.g., creating a blog post) continues to generate traffic for years, and it makes it easier for future work to succeed. The value grows exponentially over time, as shown in the chart.
This depends on your industry, budget, and starting point. For a new site, 5-10% monthly growth after the initial ramp-up is a good goal. For an established site with a solid foundation, 10-20% is achievable with a strong strategy. Look at your past growth in Google Search Console for a personalized benchmark.
Absolutely. This is a key part of the "Better Together" strategy. Your Google Ads campaign's "Search Terms" report is a goldmine. It shows you exactly which keywords are driving conversions. You can then prioritize these proven, high-intent keywords for your SEO content strategy, reducing risk and accelerating results.